A Sliver of a Full Moon, but Not the Full Moon Yet

Deborah Parker, former vice chairwoman of the Tulalip Tribes of Washington State. Photo by Susan Walsh, Associated PressDeborah Parker, former vice chairwoman of the Tulalip Tribes of Washington State. Photo by Susan Walsh, Associated Press
@ The Radcliffe Institute
November 19, 2015
By Pat Harrison

Mary Kathryn Nagle wrote the play Sliver of a Full Moon—which will be read today at the Radcliffe Institute—because Native leaders asked her to. Naglean attorney and citizen of the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma, was approached by tribal leaders in early 2013 who asked her to interview Native women survivors and share their stories. 

They were trying to explain to people—including Congressional lawmakers—why tribal governments needed their jurisdiction restored on Indian lands. A 1978 Supreme Court ruling, in Oliphant v. Suquamish Indian Tribe, had stripped tribes of criminal jurisdiction over non-Indians on tribal land. One result of this ruling was that when non-Indian men sexually assaulted Native women on Indian land, tribes did not have the authority to prosecute the assailant, and these incidents were occurring more and more frequently.

Representative Tom Cole is joined by Indian women from across the country for President Obama's signing of the Violence Against Women Act reauthorization. Cole was a cosponsor of the bill and a key House member in rallying support for the bill. The Act was signed by the President on March 7, 2013, at the US Department of Interior. Image source Chickasaw TimesRepresentative Tom Cole is joined by Indian women from across the country for President Obama's signing of the Violence Against Women Act reauthorization. Cole was a cosponsor of the bill and a key House member in rallying support for the bill. The Act was signed by the President on March 7, 2013, at the US Department of Interior. Image source Chickasaw Times

Nagle began to contact Native women who had survived these attacks and had testified before Congress in the effort to reauthorize the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA), which included provisions pertaining to the restoration of tribal jurisdiction to protect Native women. In February 2013 Nagle was setting up interviews with the women survivors. “Then all of a sudden,” she says, “VAWA passed the House.”

She was surprised. “I interviewed Congressman Tom Cole, and I asked him, ‘How did this come to be?’ He’s a Republican from Oklahoma, but he’s also a citizen of the Chickasaw Nation. Essentially, he told me he got a group of Republican Congressmen together and said, ‘Look, I know that the party leaders say you should vote against tribal jurisdiction, but here’s why I think you should vote for it.’ So the House ended up accepting the bill.” Passage of the bill in the House required 218 votes in favor, and it passed by a vote of 286 to 138.

President Obama--joined by Vice President Biden, members of women's organizations, law enforcement officials, tribal leaders, survivors, advocates and members of Congress--signs the Violence Against Women Act. Photo by Manuel Balce Ceneta, Associated PressPresident Obama--joined by Vice President Biden, members of women's organizations, law enforcement officials, tribal leaders, survivors, advocates and members of Congress--signs the Violence Against Women Act. Photo by Manuel Balce Ceneta, Associated Press

While the play was no longer needed to convince Congress to pass the bill, it was still important for other reasons. “The play has become a vehicle to educate people about the legal issues when it comes to tribes and jurisdiction over non-Indians, which are extraordinarily complicated,” Nagle says. “Even to American Indian lawyers who grow up talking about this and learning about it."

President Barack Obama, Diane Millich, and Vice President Joe Biden. Photo courtesy of Mary Kathryn NaglePresident Barack Obama, Diane Millich, and Vice President Joe Biden. Photo courtesy of Mary Kathryn NagleSliver of a Full Moon dramatizes the plight of Native women who were abused by letting us hear their personal stories. Actors play some of the characters—an actor plays Congressman Tom Cole, for example—but the women who testified before congressional leaders play themselves. The survivors who will be part of the play at Radcliffe are Lisa Brunner of the White Earth Ojibwe, Diane Millich of the Southern Ute Tribe, Billie Jo Rich of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians , and Nettie Warbelow, of the Athabaskan, from the Native Village of Tetlin. The director, Betsy Theobald Richards, like the playwright, is a member of the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma.

While Sliver of a Full Moon is a tale, in Nagle’s words, of “resistance and celebration,” there is more to do. She would like to see the decision in Johnson v. M’Intosh, the 1823 Supreme Court case that says Indians cannot claim legal title to their own lands, overturned. She would also like to see Oliphant overturned. “We had a Brown v. Board of Education in 1954 that overturned Plessy v. Ferguson, but we haven’t had that kind of progress when it comes to federal Indian law.” Nagle is eager to present the play at Harvard because, she says, “the future leaders of the United States come out of Harvard. My hope is to educate the members of that community about federal Indian law and how it has and has not failed to progress.”

Mary Kathryn Nagle. Photo courtesy of Mary Kathryn NagleMary Kathryn Nagle. Photo courtesy of Mary Kathryn Nagle

Explaining the title of the play, Nagle says it came during her interview with Lisa Brunner. “When we sat down to conduct our interview, VAWA had just passed, so I asked her how she felt about this. She said she felt great but was still a little sad because the law was just a sliver of the full moon of justice that we need to protect our Native women. I thought this was such a powerful way of explaining it that I immediately started using it as the title.”


VIEW VIDEO of Sliver of a Full Moon: A Play Reading and Discussion, which took place at the Radcliffe Instritute on November 19, 2015.

The evening was cosponsored by the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study, Harvard University Native American Program, Harvard Native American Law Students Association, Harvard Divinity School, the Standing Committee on Ethnicity, Migration, Rights and the Donald T. Regan Lecture Fund, with support from the National Indigenous Women’s Resource Center and the Office of the President and Provost.  

 

Search Year: 
2015